Paul M. Rothenberg, M.D. - Orthopaedic Surgeon

"Dr. Paul Rothenberg is truly exceptional. From our very first interaction, Dr. Rothenberg demonstrated not only outstanding surgical expertise but also an extraordinary level of compassion and professionalism. His bedside manner is unmatched--he takes the time to explain everything clearly, answers questions with patience, and genuinely makes both patients and families feel at ease during what can be a very stressful time. My mother recently underwent surgery under his care, and despite the complexity of her condition, Dr. Rothenberg handled everything with confidence, precision, and honesty. He set realistic expectations, and his attention to detail before, during, and after surgery gave us complete trust in the process. The care did not stop in the operating room--his follow-up and guidance have been just as thorough and reassuring. It is rare to find a physician who combines technical excellence with such humanity. Dr. Rothenberg is truly gifted at what he does, and we are incredibly grateful to have had him as our surgeon. I will absolutely be recommending him to anyone in need of an orthopedic specialist. Highly, highly recommended."

"Dr. Rothenberg has been absolutely amazing throughout my health and knee journey. From the very first visit, he took the time to truly listen, explain everything clearly, and make me feel confident in the treatment plan. His knowledge, professionalism, and genuine care stand out immediately. Highly recommend!"

"Best-in-Class Orthopedic Care in New Jersey Dr. Rothenberg is an outstanding orthopedic physician, and I can't recommend him highly enough. From the first visit, he was attentive, caring, and genuinely invested in my health. He took the time to listen, explained everything clearly, and always made me feel heard and comfortable. His calm, positive demeanor immediately puts you at ease. I've been dealing with injuries on and off since 2018 from bodybuilding, boxing, and a long sports background. Dr. Rothenberg has helped me through everything from A to Z, including a labral tear in my left shoulder, elbow tendonitis, knee issues, and a wrist injury that required imaging and cortisone treatment. Each time, he walked me through the problem, discussed solutions, and made sure I received the right care. He personally followed up with my X-ray results the same day and stayed involved through my wrist and shoulder MRIs, ensuring his office reached out promptly with updates. His communication and follow-through are excellent. What truly sets Dr. Rothenberg apart is that he genuinely cares. Injuries have taken a toll over the years, but he has always made me feel hopeful, confident, and supported. Seeing him feels less like a doctor's visit and more like meeting with someone you trust who truly wants to help. If you're looking for an orthopedic specialist in New Jersey, especially in Jersey City or Edgewater, I highly recommend Dr. Rothenberg."